George Orwell once said, "To see what is in front of one's nose needs a constant struggle." For some people that struggle is a life-long ordeal.
Take Nicholson Baker and
credulous reviewer in the LA Times. Baker's new book
Human Smoke purports to show that:
World War II was one of the biggest, most carefully plotted lies in modern history. According to the myth, British and American statesmen naively thought they could reason with such brutal fascists as Germany's Hitler and Japan's Tojo. Faced with this weakness, Hitler and Tojo tried to take over the world, and the United States and Britain were forced to use military might to stop them.The facts are powerful. Baker shows, step by step, how an alliance dominated by leaders who were bigoted, far more opposed to communism than to fascism, obsessed with arms sales and itching for a fight coerced the world into war.Where does one begin? With Germany's agression in Eastern Europe, telegraphed by Hitler 15 years in advance? Or maybe Japan's brutal war with China, which began in 1937*? It is so tedious to point out that Germany, Japan, and Italy were run by militaristic gangsters who were loud and proud about their plans to take over the world, or at least their neigborhoods of it. It has been documented
ad nauseum and it was no secret then or since.
The Allies were flawed, both in individual leadership and as nations. Is that news to anyone? The war is inherently inhumane and the "good guys" didn't always wear white hats**. Is that some kind of revelation? But to say WWII was optional, and sitting it out was a morally acceptable alternative is nuts.
I'll take this opportunity of throwing my wild and crazy opinion on 20th century European history: I wish Germany had won World War I. Just think of all the bad things that would not have happened had von Moltke reached Paris in September 1914, like his uncle did in 1870. Of course, one might argue that you can never know the bad things that might have happened had Germany won, but since the 20th C. was pretty bad, it's hard to imagine it being worse.
*That's more than two full years before the conventional date for the start of World War II, for those of you who need reminding.**For example, in my humble and not very important view, area bombing of cities was not morally justified.Labels: Books, Human Smoke, World War II